{"id": "DISC-0106", "item_id": "ITEM-0058", "source_id": "SRC-0116", "year": "2011", "date_precision": "year", "disclosure_method": "academic_research", "extent": "partial", "coverage": "Secrecy/discourse discussion and final historical-scope footnote.", "review_status": "reviewed", "notes": "Same-author retrospective, not independent corroboration of the 1982 report.", "item": {"id": "ITEM-0058", "tradition_id": "TRAD-0045", "name": "Age-graded male initiation: concealed bloodletting and sexual rites", "secrecy_type": "initiatory_rite", "restricted_to": "Knowledge distributed by initiation grade; particular procedures withheld from women, children and junior initiates", "restriction_mechanism": "controlled_access;grade_requirement;violence_or_threat", "stated_reason": "Herdt reports beliefs about removing maternal contamination and enabling male development; these are reported rationales, not biological findings", "current_status": "unknown", "status_as_of": "", "status_claim_ids": "", "description": "Historically documented secret initiation, coercive bodily ordeals and sexual rites involving boys and older initiates.", "notes": "Scope basis: explicit concealment and successive revelation in SRC-0111, p. 200. Sexual rites are summarized non-graphically. Same-author publications are not independent corroboration; recent practice is unestablished."}, "tradition": {"id": "TRAD-0045", "name": "Sambia male initiation in Gilbert Herdt’s field accounts", "tradition_type": "indigenous_tradition", "founded": "", "region": "Eastern Highlands, Papua New Guinea", "status": "unknown", "wikidata": "", "notes": "Name and scope follow Herdt’s accounts. Neighbouring Anga peoples and later generations are not assigned the same practices. The later chapter explicitly limits its ethnography to 1993 and notes subsequent radical change."}, "source": {"id": "SRC-0116", "title": "Talking About Sex: On the relationship between discourse, secrecy and sexual subjectivity in Melanesia", "author": "Gilbert Herdt", "original_year": "2011", "edition_year": "", "source_type": "academic", "url": "https://press-files.anu.edu.au/downloads/press/p146101/html/Text/ch12.html?page=17&referer=189", "identifiers": "", "provenance": "academic_fieldwork;scholarship", "source_authenticity": "verified", "verification_notes": "Read the publisher HTML’s distinctions between public, secret and private discourse, its six-grade discussion, its critique of earlier ethnography and its final scope footnote. Checked the official ANU Press book record for the October 2011 publication. The final footnote limits this account to research through 1993 and refers to subsequent radical change.", "rights": "copyrighted", "content_hash": "", "notes": "Chapter 12 of Echoes of the Tambaran, edited by David Lipset and Paul Roscoe. Same investigator and fieldwork lineage as SRC-0111; not an independent witness. No contemporary unchanged-practice claim follows.", "artifacts": [{"id": "ARTF-0025", "source_id": "SRC-0116", "artifact_kind": "document", "media_type": "text/html", "url": "https://press-files.anu.edu.au/downloads/press/p146101/html/Text/ch12.html?page=17&referer=189", "ipfs_cid": "", "btih": "", "member_path": "", "sha256": "d6a41e1479f2a44a7dfdfb0aa45d326eb4dae5cd4af7d3b2a1eae8b1a2beaa45", "size_bytes": "62992", "inspection_status": "partial", "inspected_parts": "Discussion of discourse categories and initiation grades; final temporal-scope footnote", "accessed_on": "2026-11-04", "notes": "Complete chapter HTML captured, selected paragraphs inspected. This retrospective shares the fieldworker and upstream material of SRC-0111."}]}, "dataset": {"name": "open-arcana", "version": "0.3.0", "metadata_license": "CC0-1.0", "snapshot_sha256": "fd755a0cc0c78cf43dac965d39908085b13b246532d888525645150e391f8e45"}, "quality_issues": [{"table": "sources", "record_id": "SRC-0116", "code": "source_without_content_hash", "message": "No source-level content_hash is recorded; linked artifact hashes may identify excerpts, derivatives or metadata instead."}, {"table": "source_artifacts", "record_id": "ARTF-0025", "code": "artifact_partial", "message": "Artifact inspection is partial; use only its recorded inspected portions."}], "claims": [{"id": "CLM-0222", "item_id": "ITEM-0058", "claim_type": "content", "suppression_method": "", "statement": "Herdt says particular nosebleeding procedures were hidden from women, children and younger initiates until successive ritual revelations.", "period": "Fieldwork in 1974–1976 and 1979, published 1982", "claim_support": "single_source", "supporting_source_ids": "SRC-0111", "independent_source_ids": "", "contradicting_source_ids": "", "locators": "SRC-0111: p. 200", "review_status": "reviewed", "verification_notes": "Core secrecy evidence checked against the page image. This is a specific graded restriction, not an inference from the topic being taboo.", "item": {"id": "ITEM-0058", "tradition_id": "TRAD-0045", "name": "Age-graded male initiation: concealed bloodletting and sexual rites", "secrecy_type": "initiatory_rite", "restricted_to": "Knowledge distributed by initiation grade; particular procedures withheld from women, children and junior initiates", "restriction_mechanism": "controlled_access;grade_requirement;violence_or_threat", "stated_reason": "Herdt reports beliefs about removing maternal contamination and enabling male development; these are reported rationales, not biological findings", "current_status": "unknown", "status_as_of": "", "status_claim_ids": "", "description": "Historically documented secret initiation, coercive bodily ordeals and sexual rites involving boys and older initiates.", "notes": "Scope basis: explicit concealment and successive revelation in SRC-0111, p. 200. Sexual rites are summarized non-graphically. Same-author publications are not independent corroboration; recent practice is unestablished."}, "tradition": {"id": "TRAD-0045", "name": "Sambia male initiation in Gilbert Herdt’s field accounts", "tradition_type": "indigenous_tradition", "founded": "", "region": "Eastern Highlands, Papua New Guinea", "status": "unknown", "wikidata": "", "notes": "Name and scope follow Herdt’s accounts. Neighbouring Anga peoples and later generations are not assigned the same practices. The later chapter explicitly limits its ethnography to 1993 and notes subsequent radical change."}, "supporting_sources": [{"id": "SRC-0111", "title": "Sambia Nosebleeding Rites and Male Proximity to Women", "author": "Gilbert H. Herdt", "original_year": "1982", "edition_year": "", "source_type": "academic", "url": "https://www.faculty.fairfield.edu/dcrawford/herdt.pdf", "identifiers": "", "provenance": "academic_fieldwork;archival_collection", "source_authenticity": "probable", "verification_notes": "Retrieved a 22-page image PDF hosted on a faculty site. Generated OCR and read selected journal pages, especially pp. 189, 192, 195–196, 200–203 and 216. Visually checked the title page and pp. 200–201. Journal pagination, not the course-reader folio numbers, supplies locators. Not every OCR line was collated.", "rights": "copyrighted", "content_hash": "", "notes": "Ethos 10(3), pp. 189–231. Title page identifies fieldwork in 1974–1976 and 1979; the p. 200 footnote dates the main ethnographic present to 1974–1976. This scan is not the book or film Guardians of the Flutes.", "artifacts": [{"id": "ARTF-0019", "source_id": "SRC-0111", "artifact_kind": "document", "media_type": "application/pdf", "url": "https://www.faculty.fairfield.edu/dcrawford/herdt.pdf", "ipfs_cid": "", "btih": "", "member_path": "", "sha256": "23a3d324108d499b1448e9f255f2607bcb48f835c5109229577ba8b56c5ef020", "size_bytes": "1886332", "inspection_status": "partial", "inspected_parts": "Selected journal pp. 189, 192, 195–196, 200–203, 208–210 and 216; title and pp. 200–201 visually checked", "accessed_on": "2026-11-04", "notes": "Complete 22-page image PDF captured. Most pages are two-page spreads; course-reader folios are not journal locators. Original scan has no extractable text."}, {"id": "ARTF-0020", "source_id": "SRC-0111", "artifact_kind": "document", "media_type": "text/plain", "url": "", "ipfs_cid": "", "btih": "", "member_path": "", "sha256": "b1924f95d569290ed02fa179d2e49e90278514bb4bcb81365a642f7fc0fec3d6", "size_bytes": "108671", "inspection_status": "partial", "inspected_parts": "Locally generated OCR: selected passages corresponding to the cited journal pages", "accessed_on": "2026-11-04", "notes": "Derivative made with pdftoppm at 1800-pixel scale and Tesseract, with PDF-page markers. Hash identifies OCR bytes, not the scan. OCR errors remain; only selected page images were collated."}]}], "contradicting_sources": [], "dataset": {"name": "open-arcana", "version": "0.3.0", "metadata_license": "CC0-1.0", "snapshot_sha256": "fd755a0cc0c78cf43dac965d39908085b13b246532d888525645150e391f8e45"}, "quality_issues": [{"table": "sources", "record_id": "SRC-0111", "code": "source_authenticity_probable", "message": "Source authenticity is probable; this is separate from the truth of its assertions."}, {"table": "sources", "record_id": "SRC-0111", "code": "source_without_content_hash", "message": "No source-level content_hash is recorded; linked artifact hashes may identify excerpts, derivatives or metadata instead."}, {"table": "source_artifacts", "record_id": "ARTF-0019", "code": "artifact_partial", "message": "Artifact inspection is partial; use only its recorded inspected portions."}, {"table": "source_artifacts", "record_id": "ARTF-0020", "code": "artifact_partial", "message": "Artifact inspection is partial; use only its recorded inspected portions."}]}, {"id": "CLM-0223", "item_id": "ITEM-0058", "claim_type": "content", "suppression_method": "", "statement": "Herdt reports enforced initiatory bloodletting alongside beatings, fasting, sleep deprivation and boys attempting escape.", "period": "Fieldwork in 1974–1976 and 1979, published 1982", "claim_support": "single_source", "supporting_source_ids": "SRC-0111", "independent_source_ids": "", "contradicting_source_ids": "", "locators": "SRC-0111: pp. 201–203", "review_status": "reviewed", "verification_notes": "Reported observations and context, summarized without an operational procedure. No evidence of unchanged current practice follows.", "item": {"id": "ITEM-0058", "tradition_id": "TRAD-0045", "name": "Age-graded male initiation: concealed bloodletting and sexual rites", "secrecy_type": "initiatory_rite", "restricted_to": "Knowledge distributed by initiation grade; particular procedures withheld from women, children and junior initiates", "restriction_mechanism": "controlled_access;grade_requirement;violence_or_threat", "stated_reason": "Herdt reports beliefs about removing maternal contamination and enabling male development; these are reported rationales, not biological findings", "current_status": "unknown", "status_as_of": "", "status_claim_ids": "", "description": "Historically documented secret initiation, coercive bodily ordeals and sexual rites involving boys and older initiates.", "notes": "Scope basis: explicit concealment and successive revelation in SRC-0111, p. 200. Sexual rites are summarized non-graphically. Same-author publications are not independent corroboration; recent practice is unestablished."}, "tradition": {"id": "TRAD-0045", "name": "Sambia male initiation in Gilbert Herdt’s field accounts", "tradition_type": "indigenous_tradition", "founded": "", "region": "Eastern Highlands, Papua New Guinea", "status": "unknown", "wikidata": "", "notes": "Name and scope follow Herdt’s accounts. Neighbouring Anga peoples and later generations are not assigned the same practices. The later chapter explicitly limits its ethnography to 1993 and notes subsequent radical change."}, "supporting_sources": [{"id": "SRC-0111", "title": "Sambia Nosebleeding Rites and Male Proximity to Women", "author": "Gilbert H. Herdt", "original_year": "1982", "edition_year": "", "source_type": "academic", "url": "https://www.faculty.fairfield.edu/dcrawford/herdt.pdf", "identifiers": "", "provenance": "academic_fieldwork;archival_collection", "source_authenticity": "probable", "verification_notes": "Retrieved a 22-page image PDF hosted on a faculty site. Generated OCR and read selected journal pages, especially pp. 189, 192, 195–196, 200–203 and 216. Visually checked the title page and pp. 200–201. Journal pagination, not the course-reader folio numbers, supplies locators. Not every OCR line was collated.", "rights": "copyrighted", "content_hash": "", "notes": "Ethos 10(3), pp. 189–231. Title page identifies fieldwork in 1974–1976 and 1979; the p. 200 footnote dates the main ethnographic present to 1974–1976. This scan is not the book or film Guardians of the Flutes.", "artifacts": [{"id": "ARTF-0019", "source_id": "SRC-0111", "artifact_kind": "document", "media_type": "application/pdf", "url": "https://www.faculty.fairfield.edu/dcrawford/herdt.pdf", "ipfs_cid": "", "btih": "", "member_path": "", "sha256": "23a3d324108d499b1448e9f255f2607bcb48f835c5109229577ba8b56c5ef020", "size_bytes": "1886332", "inspection_status": "partial", "inspected_parts": "Selected journal pp. 189, 192, 195–196, 200–203, 208–210 and 216; title and pp. 200–201 visually checked", "accessed_on": "2026-11-04", "notes": "Complete 22-page image PDF captured. Most pages are two-page spreads; course-reader folios are not journal locators. Original scan has no extractable text."}, {"id": "ARTF-0020", "source_id": "SRC-0111", "artifact_kind": "document", "media_type": "text/plain", "url": "", "ipfs_cid": "", "btih": "", "member_path": "", "sha256": "b1924f95d569290ed02fa179d2e49e90278514bb4bcb81365a642f7fc0fec3d6", "size_bytes": "108671", "inspection_status": "partial", "inspected_parts": "Locally generated OCR: selected passages corresponding to the cited journal pages", "accessed_on": "2026-11-04", "notes": "Derivative made with pdftoppm at 1800-pixel scale and Tesseract, with PDF-page markers. Hash identifies OCR bytes, not the scan. OCR errors remain; only selected page images were collated."}]}], "contradicting_sources": [], "dataset": {"name": "open-arcana", "version": "0.3.0", "metadata_license": "CC0-1.0", "snapshot_sha256": "fd755a0cc0c78cf43dac965d39908085b13b246532d888525645150e391f8e45"}, "quality_issues": [{"table": "sources", "record_id": "SRC-0111", "code": "source_authenticity_probable", "message": "Source authenticity is probable; this is separate from the truth of its assertions."}, {"table": "sources", "record_id": "SRC-0111", "code": "source_without_content_hash", "message": "No source-level content_hash is recorded; linked artifact hashes may identify excerpts, derivatives or metadata instead."}, {"table": "source_artifacts", "record_id": "ARTF-0019", "code": "artifact_partial", "message": "Artifact inspection is partial; use only its recorded inspected portions."}, {"table": "source_artifacts", "record_id": "ARTF-0020", "code": "artifact_partial", "message": "Artifact inspection is partial; use only its recorded inspected portions."}]}, {"id": "CLM-0224", "item_id": "ITEM-0058", "claim_type": "content", "suppression_method": "", "statement": "The account reports secret sexual rites involving boys and older initiates as part of male initiation.", "period": "Fieldwork in 1974–1976 and 1979, published 1982", "claim_support": "single_source", "supporting_source_ids": "SRC-0111", "independent_source_ids": "", "contradicting_source_ids": "", "locators": "SRC-0111: pp. 195–196", "review_status": "reviewed", "verification_notes": "Non-graphic summary of the reported sexual activity involving minors. It is not a claim of voluntary participation, an equivalence with adult sexual orientation, or a statement about neighbouring peoples.", "item": {"id": "ITEM-0058", "tradition_id": "TRAD-0045", "name": "Age-graded male initiation: concealed bloodletting and sexual rites", "secrecy_type": "initiatory_rite", "restricted_to": "Knowledge distributed by initiation grade; particular procedures withheld from women, children and junior initiates", "restriction_mechanism": "controlled_access;grade_requirement;violence_or_threat", "stated_reason": "Herdt reports beliefs about removing maternal contamination and enabling male development; these are reported rationales, not biological findings", "current_status": "unknown", "status_as_of": "", "status_claim_ids": "", "description": "Historically documented secret initiation, coercive bodily ordeals and sexual rites involving boys and older initiates.", "notes": "Scope basis: explicit concealment and successive revelation in SRC-0111, p. 200. Sexual rites are summarized non-graphically. Same-author publications are not independent corroboration; recent practice is unestablished."}, "tradition": {"id": "TRAD-0045", "name": "Sambia male initiation in Gilbert Herdt’s field accounts", "tradition_type": "indigenous_tradition", "founded": "", "region": "Eastern Highlands, Papua New Guinea", "status": "unknown", "wikidata": "", "notes": "Name and scope follow Herdt’s accounts. Neighbouring Anga peoples and later generations are not assigned the same practices. The later chapter explicitly limits its ethnography to 1993 and notes subsequent radical change."}, "supporting_sources": [{"id": "SRC-0111", "title": "Sambia Nosebleeding Rites and Male Proximity to Women", "author": "Gilbert H. Herdt", "original_year": "1982", "edition_year": "", "source_type": "academic", "url": "https://www.faculty.fairfield.edu/dcrawford/herdt.pdf", "identifiers": "", "provenance": "academic_fieldwork;archival_collection", "source_authenticity": "probable", "verification_notes": "Retrieved a 22-page image PDF hosted on a faculty site. Generated OCR and read selected journal pages, especially pp. 189, 192, 195–196, 200–203 and 216. Visually checked the title page and pp. 200–201. Journal pagination, not the course-reader folio numbers, supplies locators. Not every OCR line was collated.", "rights": "copyrighted", "content_hash": "", "notes": "Ethos 10(3), pp. 189–231. Title page identifies fieldwork in 1974–1976 and 1979; the p. 200 footnote dates the main ethnographic present to 1974–1976. This scan is not the book or film Guardians of the Flutes.", "artifacts": [{"id": "ARTF-0019", "source_id": "SRC-0111", "artifact_kind": "document", "media_type": "application/pdf", "url": "https://www.faculty.fairfield.edu/dcrawford/herdt.pdf", "ipfs_cid": "", "btih": "", "member_path": "", "sha256": "23a3d324108d499b1448e9f255f2607bcb48f835c5109229577ba8b56c5ef020", "size_bytes": "1886332", "inspection_status": "partial", "inspected_parts": "Selected journal pp. 189, 192, 195–196, 200–203, 208–210 and 216; title and pp. 200–201 visually checked", "accessed_on": "2026-11-04", "notes": "Complete 22-page image PDF captured. Most pages are two-page spreads; course-reader folios are not journal locators. Original scan has no extractable text."}, {"id": "ARTF-0020", "source_id": "SRC-0111", "artifact_kind": "document", "media_type": "text/plain", "url": "", "ipfs_cid": "", "btih": "", "member_path": "", "sha256": "b1924f95d569290ed02fa179d2e49e90278514bb4bcb81365a642f7fc0fec3d6", "size_bytes": "108671", "inspection_status": "partial", "inspected_parts": "Locally generated OCR: selected passages corresponding to the cited journal pages", "accessed_on": "2026-11-04", "notes": "Derivative made with pdftoppm at 1800-pixel scale and Tesseract, with PDF-page markers. Hash identifies OCR bytes, not the scan. OCR errors remain; only selected page images were collated."}]}], "contradicting_sources": [], "dataset": {"name": "open-arcana", "version": "0.3.0", "metadata_license": "CC0-1.0", "snapshot_sha256": "fd755a0cc0c78cf43dac965d39908085b13b246532d888525645150e391f8e45"}, "quality_issues": [{"table": "sources", "record_id": "SRC-0111", "code": "source_authenticity_probable", "message": "Source authenticity is probable; this is separate from the truth of its assertions."}, {"table": "sources", "record_id": "SRC-0111", "code": "source_without_content_hash", "message": "No source-level content_hash is recorded; linked artifact hashes may identify excerpts, derivatives or metadata instead."}, {"table": "source_artifacts", "record_id": "ARTF-0019", "code": "artifact_partial", "message": "Artifact inspection is partial; use only its recorded inspected portions."}, {"table": "source_artifacts", "record_id": "ARTF-0020", "code": "artifact_partial", "message": "Artifact inspection is partial; use only its recorded inspected portions."}]}, {"id": "CLM-0225", "item_id": "ITEM-0058", "claim_type": "content", "suppression_method": "", "statement": "The reported rationale treats maternal contamination as obstructing boys’ development and bloodletting as removing it.", "period": "Fieldwork in 1974–1976 and 1979, published 1982", "claim_support": "single_source", "supporting_source_ids": "SRC-0111", "independent_source_ids": "", "contradicting_source_ids": "", "locators": "SRC-0111: pp. 192, 195, 197–198", "review_status": "reviewed", "verification_notes": "A reported belief, not a biological fact or medical recommendation.", "item": {"id": "ITEM-0058", "tradition_id": "TRAD-0045", "name": "Age-graded male initiation: concealed bloodletting and sexual rites", "secrecy_type": "initiatory_rite", "restricted_to": "Knowledge distributed by initiation grade; particular procedures withheld from women, children and junior initiates", "restriction_mechanism": "controlled_access;grade_requirement;violence_or_threat", "stated_reason": "Herdt reports beliefs about removing maternal contamination and enabling male development; these are reported rationales, not biological findings", "current_status": "unknown", "status_as_of": "", "status_claim_ids": "", "description": "Historically documented secret initiation, coercive bodily ordeals and sexual rites involving boys and older initiates.", "notes": "Scope basis: explicit concealment and successive revelation in SRC-0111, p. 200. Sexual rites are summarized non-graphically. Same-author publications are not independent corroboration; recent practice is unestablished."}, "tradition": {"id": "TRAD-0045", "name": "Sambia male initiation in Gilbert Herdt’s field accounts", "tradition_type": "indigenous_tradition", "founded": "", "region": "Eastern Highlands, Papua New Guinea", "status": "unknown", "wikidata": "", "notes": "Name and scope follow Herdt’s accounts. Neighbouring Anga peoples and later generations are not assigned the same practices. The later chapter explicitly limits its ethnography to 1993 and notes subsequent radical change."}, "supporting_sources": [{"id": "SRC-0111", "title": "Sambia Nosebleeding Rites and Male Proximity to Women", "author": "Gilbert H. Herdt", "original_year": "1982", "edition_year": "", "source_type": "academic", "url": "https://www.faculty.fairfield.edu/dcrawford/herdt.pdf", "identifiers": "", "provenance": "academic_fieldwork;archival_collection", "source_authenticity": "probable", "verification_notes": "Retrieved a 22-page image PDF hosted on a faculty site. Generated OCR and read selected journal pages, especially pp. 189, 192, 195–196, 200–203 and 216. Visually checked the title page and pp. 200–201. Journal pagination, not the course-reader folio numbers, supplies locators. Not every OCR line was collated.", "rights": "copyrighted", "content_hash": "", "notes": "Ethos 10(3), pp. 189–231. Title page identifies fieldwork in 1974–1976 and 1979; the p. 200 footnote dates the main ethnographic present to 1974–1976. This scan is not the book or film Guardians of the Flutes.", "artifacts": [{"id": "ARTF-0019", "source_id": "SRC-0111", "artifact_kind": "document", "media_type": "application/pdf", "url": "https://www.faculty.fairfield.edu/dcrawford/herdt.pdf", "ipfs_cid": "", "btih": "", "member_path": "", "sha256": "23a3d324108d499b1448e9f255f2607bcb48f835c5109229577ba8b56c5ef020", "size_bytes": "1886332", "inspection_status": "partial", "inspected_parts": "Selected journal pp. 189, 192, 195–196, 200–203, 208–210 and 216; title and pp. 200–201 visually checked", "accessed_on": "2026-11-04", "notes": "Complete 22-page image PDF captured. Most pages are two-page spreads; course-reader folios are not journal locators. Original scan has no extractable text."}, {"id": "ARTF-0020", "source_id": "SRC-0111", "artifact_kind": "document", "media_type": "text/plain", "url": "", "ipfs_cid": "", "btih": "", "member_path": "", "sha256": "b1924f95d569290ed02fa179d2e49e90278514bb4bcb81365a642f7fc0fec3d6", "size_bytes": "108671", "inspection_status": "partial", "inspected_parts": "Locally generated OCR: selected passages corresponding to the cited journal pages", "accessed_on": "2026-11-04", "notes": "Derivative made with pdftoppm at 1800-pixel scale and Tesseract, with PDF-page markers. Hash identifies OCR bytes, not the scan. OCR errors remain; only selected page images were collated."}]}], "contradicting_sources": [], "dataset": {"name": "open-arcana", "version": "0.3.0", "metadata_license": "CC0-1.0", "snapshot_sha256": "fd755a0cc0c78cf43dac965d39908085b13b246532d888525645150e391f8e45"}, "quality_issues": [{"table": "sources", "record_id": "SRC-0111", "code": "source_authenticity_probable", "message": "Source authenticity is probable; this is separate from the truth of its assertions."}, {"table": "sources", "record_id": "SRC-0111", "code": "source_without_content_hash", "message": "No source-level content_hash is recorded; linked artifact hashes may identify excerpts, derivatives or metadata instead."}, {"table": "source_artifacts", "record_id": "ARTF-0019", "code": "artifact_partial", "message": "Artifact inspection is partial; use only its recorded inspected portions."}, {"table": "source_artifacts", "record_id": "ARTF-0020", "code": "artifact_partial", "message": "Artifact inspection is partial; use only its recorded inspected portions."}]}, {"id": "CLM-0226", "item_id": "ITEM-0058", "claim_type": "content", "suppression_method": "", "statement": "Herdt distinguishes forced collective initiation from later private bloodletting described as voluntary adult practice.", "period": "Fieldwork in 1974–1976 and 1979, published 1982", "claim_support": "single_source", "supporting_source_ids": "SRC-0111", "independent_source_ids": "", "contradicting_source_ids": "", "locators": "SRC-0111: p. 192", "review_status": "reviewed", "verification_notes": "The source’s developmental distinction is retained; this does not establish that an individual adult’s choice was free from social pressure.", "item": {"id": "ITEM-0058", "tradition_id": "TRAD-0045", "name": "Age-graded male initiation: concealed bloodletting and sexual rites", "secrecy_type": "initiatory_rite", "restricted_to": "Knowledge distributed by initiation grade; particular procedures withheld from women, children and junior initiates", "restriction_mechanism": "controlled_access;grade_requirement;violence_or_threat", "stated_reason": "Herdt reports beliefs about removing maternal contamination and enabling male development; these are reported rationales, not biological findings", "current_status": "unknown", "status_as_of": "", "status_claim_ids": "", "description": "Historically documented secret initiation, coercive bodily ordeals and sexual rites involving boys and older initiates.", "notes": "Scope basis: explicit concealment and successive revelation in SRC-0111, p. 200. Sexual rites are summarized non-graphically. Same-author publications are not independent corroboration; recent practice is unestablished."}, "tradition": {"id": "TRAD-0045", "name": "Sambia male initiation in Gilbert Herdt’s field accounts", "tradition_type": "indigenous_tradition", "founded": "", "region": "Eastern Highlands, Papua New Guinea", "status": "unknown", "wikidata": "", "notes": "Name and scope follow Herdt’s accounts. Neighbouring Anga peoples and later generations are not assigned the same practices. The later chapter explicitly limits its ethnography to 1993 and notes subsequent radical change."}, "supporting_sources": [{"id": "SRC-0111", "title": "Sambia Nosebleeding Rites and Male Proximity to Women", "author": "Gilbert H. Herdt", "original_year": "1982", "edition_year": "", "source_type": "academic", "url": "https://www.faculty.fairfield.edu/dcrawford/herdt.pdf", "identifiers": "", "provenance": "academic_fieldwork;archival_collection", "source_authenticity": "probable", "verification_notes": "Retrieved a 22-page image PDF hosted on a faculty site. Generated OCR and read selected journal pages, especially pp. 189, 192, 195–196, 200–203 and 216. Visually checked the title page and pp. 200–201. Journal pagination, not the course-reader folio numbers, supplies locators. Not every OCR line was collated.", "rights": "copyrighted", "content_hash": "", "notes": "Ethos 10(3), pp. 189–231. Title page identifies fieldwork in 1974–1976 and 1979; the p. 200 footnote dates the main ethnographic present to 1974–1976. This scan is not the book or film Guardians of the Flutes.", "artifacts": [{"id": "ARTF-0019", "source_id": "SRC-0111", "artifact_kind": "document", "media_type": "application/pdf", "url": "https://www.faculty.fairfield.edu/dcrawford/herdt.pdf", "ipfs_cid": "", "btih": "", "member_path": "", "sha256": "23a3d324108d499b1448e9f255f2607bcb48f835c5109229577ba8b56c5ef020", "size_bytes": "1886332", "inspection_status": "partial", "inspected_parts": "Selected journal pp. 189, 192, 195–196, 200–203, 208–210 and 216; title and pp. 200–201 visually checked", "accessed_on": "2026-11-04", "notes": "Complete 22-page image PDF captured. Most pages are two-page spreads; course-reader folios are not journal locators. Original scan has no extractable text."}, {"id": "ARTF-0020", "source_id": "SRC-0111", "artifact_kind": "document", "media_type": "text/plain", "url": "", "ipfs_cid": "", "btih": "", "member_path": "", "sha256": "b1924f95d569290ed02fa179d2e49e90278514bb4bcb81365a642f7fc0fec3d6", "size_bytes": "108671", "inspection_status": "partial", "inspected_parts": "Locally generated OCR: selected passages corresponding to the cited journal pages", "accessed_on": "2026-11-04", "notes": "Derivative made with pdftoppm at 1800-pixel scale and Tesseract, with PDF-page markers. Hash identifies OCR bytes, not the scan. OCR errors remain; only selected page images were collated."}]}], "contradicting_sources": [], "dataset": {"name": "open-arcana", "version": "0.3.0", "metadata_license": "CC0-1.0", "snapshot_sha256": "fd755a0cc0c78cf43dac965d39908085b13b246532d888525645150e391f8e45"}, "quality_issues": [{"table": "sources", "record_id": "SRC-0111", "code": "source_authenticity_probable", "message": "Source authenticity is probable; this is separate from the truth of its assertions."}, {"table": "sources", "record_id": "SRC-0111", "code": "source_without_content_hash", "message": "No source-level content_hash is recorded; linked artifact hashes may identify excerpts, derivatives or metadata instead."}, {"table": "source_artifacts", "record_id": "ARTF-0019", "code": "artifact_partial", "message": "Artifact inspection is partial; use only its recorded inspected portions."}, {"table": "source_artifacts", "record_id": "ARTF-0020", "code": "artifact_partial", "message": "Artifact inspection is partial; use only its recorded inspected portions."}]}, {"id": "CLM-0227", "item_id": "ITEM-0058", "claim_type": "other", "suppression_method": "", "statement": "Herdt criticizes earlier writing for playing down initiates’ fear and reports participants recalling that they expected to be killed.", "period": "Fieldwork in 1974–1976 and 1979, published 1982", "claim_support": "single_source", "supporting_source_ids": "SRC-0111", "independent_source_ids": "", "contradicting_source_ids": "", "locators": "SRC-0111: p. 216, footnote", "review_status": "reviewed", "verification_notes": "An attributed scholarly criticism and reported recollection. It does not identify or prove a particular suppressed publication or an executed secrecy punishment.", "item": {"id": "ITEM-0058", "tradition_id": "TRAD-0045", "name": "Age-graded male initiation: concealed bloodletting and sexual rites", "secrecy_type": "initiatory_rite", "restricted_to": "Knowledge distributed by initiation grade; particular procedures withheld from women, children and junior initiates", "restriction_mechanism": "controlled_access;grade_requirement;violence_or_threat", "stated_reason": "Herdt reports beliefs about removing maternal contamination and enabling male development; these are reported rationales, not biological findings", "current_status": "unknown", "status_as_of": "", "status_claim_ids": "", "description": "Historically documented secret initiation, coercive bodily ordeals and sexual rites involving boys and older initiates.", "notes": "Scope basis: explicit concealment and successive revelation in SRC-0111, p. 200. Sexual rites are summarized non-graphically. Same-author publications are not independent corroboration; recent practice is unestablished."}, "tradition": {"id": "TRAD-0045", "name": "Sambia male initiation in Gilbert Herdt’s field accounts", "tradition_type": "indigenous_tradition", "founded": "", "region": "Eastern Highlands, Papua New Guinea", "status": "unknown", "wikidata": "", "notes": "Name and scope follow Herdt’s accounts. Neighbouring Anga peoples and later generations are not assigned the same practices. The later chapter explicitly limits its ethnography to 1993 and notes subsequent radical change."}, "supporting_sources": [{"id": "SRC-0111", "title": "Sambia Nosebleeding Rites and Male Proximity to Women", "author": "Gilbert H. Herdt", "original_year": "1982", "edition_year": "", "source_type": "academic", "url": "https://www.faculty.fairfield.edu/dcrawford/herdt.pdf", "identifiers": "", "provenance": "academic_fieldwork;archival_collection", "source_authenticity": "probable", "verification_notes": "Retrieved a 22-page image PDF hosted on a faculty site. Generated OCR and read selected journal pages, especially pp. 189, 192, 195–196, 200–203 and 216. Visually checked the title page and pp. 200–201. Journal pagination, not the course-reader folio numbers, supplies locators. Not every OCR line was collated.", "rights": "copyrighted", "content_hash": "", "notes": "Ethos 10(3), pp. 189–231. Title page identifies fieldwork in 1974–1976 and 1979; the p. 200 footnote dates the main ethnographic present to 1974–1976. This scan is not the book or film Guardians of the Flutes.", "artifacts": [{"id": "ARTF-0019", "source_id": "SRC-0111", "artifact_kind": "document", "media_type": "application/pdf", "url": "https://www.faculty.fairfield.edu/dcrawford/herdt.pdf", "ipfs_cid": "", "btih": "", "member_path": "", "sha256": "23a3d324108d499b1448e9f255f2607bcb48f835c5109229577ba8b56c5ef020", "size_bytes": "1886332", "inspection_status": "partial", "inspected_parts": "Selected journal pp. 189, 192, 195–196, 200–203, 208–210 and 216; title and pp. 200–201 visually checked", "accessed_on": "2026-11-04", "notes": "Complete 22-page image PDF captured. Most pages are two-page spreads; course-reader folios are not journal locators. Original scan has no extractable text."}, {"id": "ARTF-0020", "source_id": "SRC-0111", "artifact_kind": "document", "media_type": "text/plain", "url": "", "ipfs_cid": "", "btih": "", "member_path": "", "sha256": "b1924f95d569290ed02fa179d2e49e90278514bb4bcb81365a642f7fc0fec3d6", "size_bytes": "108671", "inspection_status": "partial", "inspected_parts": "Locally generated OCR: selected passages corresponding to the cited journal pages", "accessed_on": "2026-11-04", "notes": "Derivative made with pdftoppm at 1800-pixel scale and Tesseract, with PDF-page markers. Hash identifies OCR bytes, not the scan. OCR errors remain; only selected page images were collated."}]}], "contradicting_sources": [], "dataset": {"name": "open-arcana", "version": "0.3.0", "metadata_license": "CC0-1.0", "snapshot_sha256": "fd755a0cc0c78cf43dac965d39908085b13b246532d888525645150e391f8e45"}, "quality_issues": [{"table": "sources", "record_id": "SRC-0111", "code": "source_authenticity_probable", "message": "Source authenticity is probable; this is separate from the truth of its assertions."}, {"table": "sources", "record_id": "SRC-0111", "code": "source_without_content_hash", "message": "No source-level content_hash is recorded; linked artifact hashes may identify excerpts, derivatives or metadata instead."}, {"table": "source_artifacts", "record_id": "ARTF-0019", "code": "artifact_partial", "message": "Artifact inspection is partial; use only its recorded inspected portions."}, {"table": "source_artifacts", "record_id": "ARTF-0020", "code": "artifact_partial", "message": "Artifact inspection is partial; use only its recorded inspected portions."}]}, {"id": "CLM-0228", "item_id": "ITEM-0058", "claim_type": "content", "suppression_method": "", "statement": "Herdt distinguishes public, secret and private discourse, linking graded ritual knowledge to successive initiations.", "period": "2011 retrospective chapter; ethnography through 1993", "claim_support": "single_source", "supporting_source_ids": "SRC-0116", "independent_source_ids": "", "contradicting_source_ids": "", "locators": "SRC-0116: discussion of the three discourse categories and six initiation grades", "review_status": "reviewed", "verification_notes": "Same author and fieldwork lineage as SRC-0111. No claim of independent corroboration is made.", "item": {"id": "ITEM-0058", "tradition_id": "TRAD-0045", "name": "Age-graded male initiation: concealed bloodletting and sexual rites", "secrecy_type": "initiatory_rite", "restricted_to": "Knowledge distributed by initiation grade; particular procedures withheld from women, children and junior initiates", "restriction_mechanism": "controlled_access;grade_requirement;violence_or_threat", "stated_reason": "Herdt reports beliefs about removing maternal contamination and enabling male development; these are reported rationales, not biological findings", "current_status": "unknown", "status_as_of": "", "status_claim_ids": "", "description": "Historically documented secret initiation, coercive bodily ordeals and sexual rites involving boys and older initiates.", "notes": "Scope basis: explicit concealment and successive revelation in SRC-0111, p. 200. Sexual rites are summarized non-graphically. Same-author publications are not independent corroboration; recent practice is unestablished."}, "tradition": {"id": "TRAD-0045", "name": "Sambia male initiation in Gilbert Herdt’s field accounts", "tradition_type": "indigenous_tradition", "founded": "", "region": "Eastern Highlands, Papua New Guinea", "status": "unknown", "wikidata": "", "notes": "Name and scope follow Herdt’s accounts. Neighbouring Anga peoples and later generations are not assigned the same practices. The later chapter explicitly limits its ethnography to 1993 and notes subsequent radical change."}, "supporting_sources": [{"id": "SRC-0116", "title": "Talking About Sex: On the relationship between discourse, secrecy and sexual subjectivity in Melanesia", "author": "Gilbert Herdt", "original_year": "2011", "edition_year": "", "source_type": "academic", "url": "https://press-files.anu.edu.au/downloads/press/p146101/html/Text/ch12.html?page=17&referer=189", "identifiers": "", "provenance": "academic_fieldwork;scholarship", "source_authenticity": "verified", "verification_notes": "Read the publisher HTML’s distinctions between public, secret and private discourse, its six-grade discussion, its critique of earlier ethnography and its final scope footnote. Checked the official ANU Press book record for the October 2011 publication. The final footnote limits this account to research through 1993 and refers to subsequent radical change.", "rights": "copyrighted", "content_hash": "", "notes": "Chapter 12 of Echoes of the Tambaran, edited by David Lipset and Paul Roscoe. Same investigator and fieldwork lineage as SRC-0111; not an independent witness. No contemporary unchanged-practice claim follows.", "artifacts": [{"id": "ARTF-0025", "source_id": "SRC-0116", "artifact_kind": "document", "media_type": "text/html", "url": "https://press-files.anu.edu.au/downloads/press/p146101/html/Text/ch12.html?page=17&referer=189", "ipfs_cid": "", "btih": "", "member_path": "", "sha256": "d6a41e1479f2a44a7dfdfb0aa45d326eb4dae5cd4af7d3b2a1eae8b1a2beaa45", "size_bytes": "62992", "inspection_status": "partial", "inspected_parts": "Discussion of discourse categories and initiation grades; final temporal-scope footnote", "accessed_on": "2026-11-04", "notes": "Complete chapter HTML captured, selected paragraphs inspected. This retrospective shares the fieldworker and upstream material of SRC-0111."}]}], "contradicting_sources": [], "dataset": {"name": "open-arcana", "version": "0.3.0", "metadata_license": "CC0-1.0", "snapshot_sha256": "fd755a0cc0c78cf43dac965d39908085b13b246532d888525645150e391f8e45"}, "quality_issues": [{"table": "sources", "record_id": "SRC-0116", "code": "source_without_content_hash", "message": "No source-level content_hash is recorded; linked artifact hashes may identify excerpts, derivatives or metadata instead."}, {"table": "source_artifacts", "record_id": "ARTF-0025", "code": "artifact_partial", "message": "Artifact inspection is partial; use only its recorded inspected portions."}]}, {"id": "CLM-0229", "item_id": "ITEM-0058", "claim_type": "other", "suppression_method": "", "statement": "The later chapter explicitly limits its ethnographic focus to research through 1993 and notes radical change in subsequent fieldwork.", "period": "2011 retrospective chapter", "claim_support": "single_source", "supporting_source_ids": "SRC-0116", "independent_source_ids": "", "contradicting_source_ids": "", "locators": "SRC-0116: final footnote", "review_status": "reviewed", "verification_notes": "A limit on the source’s temporal coverage, not evidence sufficient to mark the entire rite discontinued or to date a specific change.", "item": {"id": "ITEM-0058", "tradition_id": "TRAD-0045", "name": "Age-graded male initiation: concealed bloodletting and sexual rites", "secrecy_type": "initiatory_rite", "restricted_to": "Knowledge distributed by initiation grade; particular procedures withheld from women, children and junior initiates", "restriction_mechanism": "controlled_access;grade_requirement;violence_or_threat", "stated_reason": "Herdt reports beliefs about removing maternal contamination and enabling male development; these are reported rationales, not biological findings", "current_status": "unknown", "status_as_of": "", "status_claim_ids": "", "description": "Historically documented secret initiation, coercive bodily ordeals and sexual rites involving boys and older initiates.", "notes": "Scope basis: explicit concealment and successive revelation in SRC-0111, p. 200. Sexual rites are summarized non-graphically. Same-author publications are not independent corroboration; recent practice is unestablished."}, "tradition": {"id": "TRAD-0045", "name": "Sambia male initiation in Gilbert Herdt’s field accounts", "tradition_type": "indigenous_tradition", "founded": "", "region": "Eastern Highlands, Papua New Guinea", "status": "unknown", "wikidata": "", "notes": "Name and scope follow Herdt’s accounts. Neighbouring Anga peoples and later generations are not assigned the same practices. The later chapter explicitly limits its ethnography to 1993 and notes subsequent radical change."}, "supporting_sources": [{"id": "SRC-0116", "title": "Talking About Sex: On the relationship between discourse, secrecy and sexual subjectivity in Melanesia", "author": "Gilbert Herdt", "original_year": "2011", "edition_year": "", "source_type": "academic", "url": "https://press-files.anu.edu.au/downloads/press/p146101/html/Text/ch12.html?page=17&referer=189", "identifiers": "", "provenance": "academic_fieldwork;scholarship", "source_authenticity": "verified", "verification_notes": "Read the publisher HTML’s distinctions between public, secret and private discourse, its six-grade discussion, its critique of earlier ethnography and its final scope footnote. Checked the official ANU Press book record for the October 2011 publication. The final footnote limits this account to research through 1993 and refers to subsequent radical change.", "rights": "copyrighted", "content_hash": "", "notes": "Chapter 12 of Echoes of the Tambaran, edited by David Lipset and Paul Roscoe. Same investigator and fieldwork lineage as SRC-0111; not an independent witness. No contemporary unchanged-practice claim follows.", "artifacts": [{"id": "ARTF-0025", "source_id": "SRC-0116", "artifact_kind": "document", "media_type": "text/html", "url": "https://press-files.anu.edu.au/downloads/press/p146101/html/Text/ch12.html?page=17&referer=189", "ipfs_cid": "", "btih": "", "member_path": "", "sha256": "d6a41e1479f2a44a7dfdfb0aa45d326eb4dae5cd4af7d3b2a1eae8b1a2beaa45", "size_bytes": "62992", "inspection_status": "partial", "inspected_parts": "Discussion of discourse categories and initiation grades; final temporal-scope footnote", "accessed_on": "2026-11-04", "notes": "Complete chapter HTML captured, selected paragraphs inspected. This retrospective shares the fieldworker and upstream material of SRC-0111."}]}], "contradicting_sources": [], "dataset": {"name": "open-arcana", "version": "0.3.0", "metadata_license": "CC0-1.0", "snapshot_sha256": "fd755a0cc0c78cf43dac965d39908085b13b246532d888525645150e391f8e45"}, "quality_issues": [{"table": "sources", "record_id": "SRC-0116", "code": "source_without_content_hash", "message": "No source-level content_hash is recorded; linked artifact hashes may identify excerpts, derivatives or metadata instead."}, {"table": "source_artifacts", "record_id": "ARTF-0025", "code": "artifact_partial", "message": "Artifact inspection is partial; use only its recorded inspected portions."}]}]}